Why invest in Israel and how do Israeli founders expand to the US? By Cynthia Phitoussi
Cynthia Phitoussi, Co-Founder & Managing Partner SeedIL Ventures talks about investing in Israel and explains the major differences between American and Israeli founders and shares the best qualities of both. We also discussed the major changes in the Israeli startup ecosystem that Cynthia saw over the past 7 years.
Cynthia's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/cynthia-phitoussi-b306921b/
SeedIL Ventures: https://seedil.com/
The book about learning most critical soft skills: https://chutzpahcenter.com/book/
0:05 They're releasing to fundraising video a podcast about fundraising for early-stage startups. The major rules that we follow here is no bullshit on this podcast. No music to relax. You know, advertisements of our sponsors. We only talk about fundraising here and nothing else. So let's jump into the episode. And today's a guest speaker, we have seen therapy to see co-founder and managing partner at seed ill Bank. Teachers. And in this episode, we'll talk about investing in Israel and comparing that invest into investing in the United States. Founders was the major difference between two countries and specifically Founders in them. And what are the major challenges that Israel and other outside of the stirrups have while expanding to the United States. So Cynthia, let's kick it out by here. Giving us some background on yourself and on sidel Ventures. Not sure if I'm frozen Right?
1:01 And we more likely face he died L, did I? Yeah for Israel. Okay, all right. Thanks for having me. First of all, pleasure to be there on your podcast and I hope we can spend some interesting time together. So why you wanted me to first introduce myself right? My backpack. That's right. So I had, I would say three parts in my career. Generally, I'm from France then I moved to the UK and finally 12 years ago now I moved to Israel, Tel Aviv. So I'm saying I had free path, also Geographic geographically but also in my career because my career in the startups last investment, ecosystem only started in Israel because I felt this was really the right place to do it and beforehand in Paris and London.
1:59 I had Some experience in market, research for loud, fmcg companies, and for as a consultant, as well. And then I had my own company. I was an entrepreneur for like six years. And before I move to Israel with my family, I sold my company there. So essentially I had free pass, but in the startup / investment story or interesting part for today. I also had two different paths. I would say, I started by standing together with my partner partner today, Audrey.
2:39 We found it together, a startup accelerator called, the Hive for new immigrants, to Israel, who want to start their own product and that was the best introduction. We could get to this amazing ecosystem in Israel. And then from 2014 onwards, He started investing in Israeli startups, through a cloud of investment first that then transformed into a fund since 2008. So today, all in all we have a portfolio of 25 Israeli startup. 22 are still active today and that's what we do.
3:22 Nice. I love the size of portfolio and best of luck with the mods are active. So let's let's actually start with discussing the portfolio. Companies specifically would you like to invest in in terms of geographically of course it's Israel and with the sector stage and average excise that you usually bright, right? So about the geography that this product can be Israeli related. Meaning that it also includes Israeli Founders that lead. Square. Typically they would like down their company in the US and that's absolutely accepted. But what's important for us is that they have these Israeli DNA and I will explain why a bit later because we are big big believer that Israeli. Founders, have something special that we can find in any other types of Founders.
4:14 So that's about the Geography about the sector. We basically are very agnostic, we like to Take bets in many different sectors and we don't want to limit ourselves because Israel has really positioned itself. As a leader in many sectors recently. If it was like historically known for cyber medical, maybe agritech like more recently, it has really become a leader. Also, in fintech in b2c to think of ways, in automotive, if you think of mobile eye and in many Any more factors of course. Security cybersecurity is also traditionally known that.
4:58 Even in food tax, you can find really interesting opportunities here and so on and so forth. So we didn't want to limit ourselves in terms of sectors, the only factors we wouldn't touch are the Pure medical, like medical device and pharmaceutical, and what we call heavy Hardware. So, on the tip microprocessors and all these things we wouldn't touch simply because we feel they are not adapted to our model to the size of the ticket, the ticket size that we would invest and and the time as well. So the capital that is going to be needed along the way for these kind of companies is not suited to our strategy but usually it's also super interesting to invest in these sectors.
5:44 I'm not saying deep Tech is fun, indeed, we're bringing more and more deep Tech Founders because The idea that they just come up on with fundraising video that they're just absolutely insane. Like I'm about to interview guy who is inventing actual jet pack. It was just fun, you know, you cannot miss this kind of stuff. All right. So now let's talk a little more about the what you mentioned earlier, which is Universe, only Founders who have this is really India, and they can you tell us a little more about that? What's so special about Israeli and DNA? Yeah, I would first remind you that what's absolutely amazing today. I think it's the number of unicorns in this country. We have in a country that is probably as small as. I don't know why.
6:32 I know about like a region in France, a small region in France, maybe New Jersey. I'm not sure what I'm saying now, but it's really a tiny, tiny country of less than 9 million people. There, we have 65 unicorn, 65 unicorns are founded by Israeli Founders. So, like I said, sometimes they move their company then, but these guys were educated here, they were born raised and and usually have a very, very strong Israeli DNA. So what what I find specific here is definitely.
7:12 First of all, that these entrepreneurs are very, very resilient and this is something that you need. Need, when you are an entrepreneur because as you know, the journey is long, it's hard, it's ups and down and you have to be capable of being resilient and why Israeli are resilient. Because obviously, the country is very special politically, it's a country that is surrounded by countries that they are not really friends with. They have to go through the Army since a very young age. So, like at 18 years old, every girl and boy in this country. Go Group 2 to 3 years of army where they develop a lot of skills.
7:56 It's usually, for example, the best cyber pools somehow takes place in the Israeli Army cyber programming, but also all kinds of other skills, like leadership, for example, at the age of 18, you see, young people who get to manage themes of 2030 to select them to deal with them. And so on and so forth. So this makes them very, very strong. People that get to know how to work one with the other very, very often, you see things where the founders met at the Army and and know each other super well and know how they will overcome all sorts of issues along the way. And, you know, that the partnership between Founders is really one of the number one reason for failing. So if you know, your partner, well, You've gone through very, very tough situations with him in the past, you're likely to be able to work out with him as a as a start-up founder. So I would say this is number one, the resilient number two is that they really think big Israeli never considered that. Israel is a market because it's only a nine million people come trees.
9:15 So it's no Market essentially. So they will automatically think International. They will never. Unless like, they can maybe do like a Sandbox here. I may be a pilot or something like that, but very, very quickly. They will have the ambition to Target the world. Starting with the u.s. in many, many cases, but also other countries, they are very well positioned your graphically. So we have here Europe, really close, and also in terms of timelines and also the Middle East. And with all the recent peace agreement that Israel has made this year with Dubai. We've Morocco and and about seven or eight countries, it has started also to become a very very interesting Market just around us and obviously the US which remains number one target market for Israelis. So think thinking big means that they really give the means and the resources to do that and even if they are speed startup, they won't hesitate to travel when it was allowed until recently.
10:21 The to travel the world to take the plane as they would take the met the the underground to you know, they have a meeting and they go there they don't really they don't get, I would say shy. They have what's called in Yiddish, we call it. The hutzpah the hutzpah is basically to be like the boldness to, to their to their things. But in a good way like you, Can be, it can be perceived as negative but in this occasion is really positive. It's to their big things and not to be ashamed and Israelis have that in big because of the education.
11:05 I think that they received, they are allowed to question adults. They are the same level. There is no hierarchy with your book, with your teacher, with your parents. This is something also very, very specific to Israelis and they apply Hi it to the real life. So they would dare to go and speak with the CEO of a major American corporation. They wouldn't care. They wouldn't mind. Okay. And I would add one more thing Israelis are very Tech oriented. They're very good at technology because very often entrepreneurs here come out of the equivalent of the MIT like a university called the technion on another one.
11:51 Well, the Ben-Gurion University, they're excellent universities and they learn a lot of these Technologies also in the Army. So very often they come out of the army, they work a little bit and then they have an idea. Sometimes even that they got from the Army tell that they will convert into something actionable in real life, but it starts from the technology that's where there are the really, really, really good and then this technology could be turned into Thing, like, we see often that the same technology applies to medical and maybe in the next year, they will realize this Market is tough. So they will turn it into something for whatever I agree.
12:34 But it's essentially the same technology. So this is also another set of Israeli entrepreneurs that we really like and we think they have a very high barrier to entry often. They are offering Superior Solutions. In many cases with very Very little mean. He's nice. I love how much benefit is really, no measure provides a remember Russian army. It would release my was again, it would just teach you how to March. That's that's pretty much all it's hot here. So what's actually talk about the expansion to United States, you mentioned that, you know, Israeli companies. I've always have this Global approach in mind because I'm Google it. They population of Israel is slightly below 9 million people, which is lower.
13:21 Then population of Los Angeles alone. And so is pretty small. So let's talk about that expansion to the United States. What are the major issues that Founders from Israel specifically face when they start expanding to the United States, right? So, I think had, they are very, very tempted by the US market. They see really the American dream, they are. They really love American mentality and often? They think that they are closed. Those in their culture. And I think it's true. That the American culture is the closest you could find probably to Israelis because they're very different to European. For example, if I compare an Israeli to British guy or to a french guy, they are just the opposite. Same with the Asian people, the opposite as well. But with American people and target market, they understand each other pretty well.
14:18 They usually speak. Excellent English. I would say that the main challenge would remain in the commercial side of things, and there's also a cultural Gap, they sometimes don't perceive it, but it exists. I think it could happen. That actually, this boldness that I was talking about before may be perceived as completely not politically correct in the US for example. And they wouldn't even realize it as like, as I said, they are good in technology and the flip side of that is that they are sometimes less good. In commercial approach in storytelling, they can talk about their technology for hours in super deep details. But when it comes to tell their story in an attractive way, they sometimes meet that and it even show even shows, you know, in their appearance Israelis are not very attached to the appearance.
15:12 Even you wouldn't see any Israeli wearing, for example, you know, suit or tie it would happen once probably on their wedding day and even though It could even not wear that they're not, they don't like the appearance, they like the death of things so it can reflect and it can be sometimes a problem when they get to a meeting with corporate in the US, for example, if it had the startup level, it's fine. If it's accepted but sometimes they don't really know how to behave and how to tell, right? That's, that's a problem with a lot of early. See, Challengers special, early-stage Tech Founders, very common problem. They just do not know how to tell their story which is unfortunate, but a lot of accelerators help with that soap. I'll recommend to people from outside of the US. If you're thinking about expanding here, check out accelerators.
16:03 They're going to teach you ton of good stuff here and connect you with their networks, which can be extremely, extremely helpful. All right, let's let's actually talk about that. Maybe some advice to those Founders who are not in the United States right now. But really, really warm to go to the US - are some tools that you would like to recommend them. Be there is Really cool story of how an Israeli and foundered expand his or her company to the United States. And do you think that method is applicable to other Founders, something like that may be part of or like most of our portfolio are, there are have expanded to the US. Like I said, this is their first target market. So we see that in many different ways. If it's targeting American clients, if it's starting an operation in the US or hiring and maybe a sales team from the US and finally up to moving to the US or opening a full operation in the US.
17:00 So we see all kinds of scenarios and actually, I don't know if there's really one particular recommendation. I know that Israeli entrepreneurs in the u.s. they very much use the network of other Israelis, because there are so many bread in the Silicon Valley now in Texas, as well. And also in New York of course, even in l.a. they are for example like accelerator program specifically for Israeli Founders in the US that help them with all the tools older, you know, the tax and legal and and connections and tone and support to. I would definitely recommend Israeli Founders to do that, but they already know it.
17:46 I don't need to tell them and they all have friends, Founders already there in the US. That that kind of know all the shortcuts. Oh, for sure. This is something they would do. Sometimes I think and things that aren't were probably go before the covid and now less true. Sometimes if they are you know shorting cash and they don't really have the means to travel to meet with the customers. For example, we had a company in the past that didn't stick He's in the US market because they were selling software for hospitals and basically it would have required them to move there because they really needed to sell and to show the product and to be on premise because of all the security things and they didn't realize that early enough or they didn't have the right means to do it early enough.
18:43 So in the end with the very long cell cycles with hospitals, and so on, they didn't succeed on the other side we see in. Other market. And now after me, no, during or after covid, I can tell you that a lot of our startups have managed to sell huge contracts to really very large corporate without, even moving from their garden, and that has been absolutely fascinating for me to everything. Remote. We are like so far do you graphically, but they could really sell a lot of major contracts to Fortune 500 companies. and I think things that were right before, I'm not right anymore today, 100%, yes, covid definitely changed that. And I mean, it's cool.
19:32 I really didn't like seeing Founders having just like being forced to move to the United States physically just to meet with customers and investors that that was not a typical part of it. So yes, very happy to see that transition. So the majority of our listeners are actual American founders of based in the United States, most likely originally from the United States, any advice to those people, maybe there is some particular skill that you think of American Founders could. Learn from foreigners, may be like there's some book that could teach them something or just saying, watch them, there's a great book called hutzpah actually. So we were talking about that notion before the this boldness, a book written by somebody called the in Bel Air.
20:16 Really. And this book is in English, it's absolutely amazing. It explains all the reason behind the startup Nation it, where the startup Nation a nation of entrepreneurs. And how it starts from childhood till to to the the Army and then in the corporate world and so on and so forth. And they really give a lot of different tips about how to really take these ingredients. May be called for rain entrepreneur and to try to adopt a few of them. Even if a lot of them are very specific because of the situation of the country, but I think if you can be taken and and she says that her Buys like a muscle that can be trained so like the like you should train your like your way of Daring things, you should train it as you would for a foreign passports, for example.
21:10 So I think this notion is super interesting and I would strongly recommend these entrepreneurs to to read this book. Alright, so on this very positive note, let me ask you one more question and then we'll move on to the standard call to action question. So first question is, I mean, last question is actually once again about the expansion to United States. Do you think some companies actually do not have to expense to the US or to me or other foreign markets? Maybe have you seen some companies that just started in Israel? And there were like, okay, that's that's actually good enough for us. Have you seen any of those successes? No, no not a single company.
21:52 Would remain in Israeli to small country, some may have excluded the US market and and went to the European market. For example, we had an exit in a company called present. So that is in the industry 4.0 like, maintenance prediction for like lots of machines in, in the factories, these guys realize that they, they have some Major competition in the u.s. is that it would have required them, huge amounts in marketing and they decided to go to Europe and in particular to the German market and there they really succeeded enough to get acquired eventually and and they identified the right Market there. So I think they were right to exclude in that occasion, the us.
22:43 But I think apart from them, all of our products are in the US and that Also, what investors are looking for in it? Like a startup that wood wooden Target. The US market would be would be probably perceived as weird animal. All right, understood. Yes, I know that that happens. I've seen a lot of small countries, specifically, like with the population below, 50 million people. So yes very, very understandable and makes a lot of sense. All right, now on this. Now we're moving on to To the last question of today's episode, which is a call to action. So Cynthia, won't do want to listen to do as soon as the episode is over. I would love them to do know, first of all, researcher to us any Israeli founder that may be hidden in the u.s. If we have here, only American listeners. So if you have any idea of hidden Israeli Founders that would like to send our way, if you find them absolutely outstanding, send them away info at Cil.com and for the rest. I would love people to think of Israel differently. Maybe next time, they hear about an Israeli startup to look into it more carefully to look into all the characteristics that I said before and to start
24:13 thinking how, like, how different it could be and how it can influence them. Hmm, right. I mean, 65 unicorns, born that in the country the size smaller than Los Angeles that is It's very, very, very impressive. Yeah, great call to action. I'll be sure to leave all links to Cil in the description to Subs owed. There is also going to be a link to Cynthia's LinkedIn and also there's gonna be a link to that book called hot to Sosa. Ho ho. Ho, who's that? Alright, I was close enough. I would I did my best all full up with Cynthia to make sure I'm actually attaching the right book. So people eat, you want to train that muscle? That is reeling.
24:54 Failure seem to have definitely check Check out the description of this episode and there will be some good stuff there. And as usually have a good