What is a down-round and how to survive one? By Russ Wilcox
Russ Wilcox, Partner at PillarVC talks about his experience running startups himself. Throughout his career he raised 10 times and 3 times these were down-rounds. In this episode Russ explains what down-rounds are bad, how they happened to him and how he managed to survive and thrive!
Russ' LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/russ-wilcox-2005/
Pillar VC's website: https://www.pillar.vc/
For people who want to understand how to get in touch with the right investor, a course developed by Fundraising Radio's team and myself: https://fundraising-courses.com/
Some topics we have covered in this episode:
- your fund invests in three fields, which one of those do you specialize in?
- you've raised 10 rounds of funding and 3 of those were down-rounds with an eventual happy ending, can you tell us a bit more about that experience?
- the unique trait of your fund is that most of your managers have experience building their own companies, how transferrable is that experience?
- you're an investor who likes patents, why is that and when o you think it makes sense to patent an idea/technology?
- you've recently closed your own raise for your 3rd fund - how did that go? How does that experience compare to fundraising for your own company?
- are there any deep tech investments that you've recently made that excite you the most?
0:05 They're releasing to fundraising video a podcast about fundraising for early-stage startups, the major rule that we follow here is no bullshit on this podcast. No music to relax. You know, advertisements of our sponsors. We only talk about fundraising here and nothing else. So let's jump into the episode and today's guest speaker we have Rose Wilcox partner and peeler vcn. In this episode we'll talk about first of all, pillar receive See how you come to life, and how this is Russ's. Third fund that you raised. But before that, we're going to talk about Ross's company that he started and how he has managed to close 10 rounds of funding and how he managed to survive, three of those rounds being down rounds. And also for those people who don't know what a Down Round is we are going to explain this and explain the dangers of a Down Round.
0:53 So as let's kick it off by you, giving us some background on yourself and on pillar, we see ya. Good morning Constantine, glad to be here background on myself. I'm started my career as an entrepreneur, I started three companies. The most important which is e ink, which had all those funding rounds, you talked about and then one in clean energy and one in life science. So I really have had a career focused on commercializing Innovation, mostly science-based Innovation and then Angel Investing in other, kites of other types of startups, which led me to Reunite about five years ago, with one of my good friends, Jamie Goldstein and Sarah Hodges and they had started a new Venture fund called pillar which we'll talk about. And at Pillar.
1:43 Now, I'm a general partner and I focus on making investments in any kind of innovative company, maybe, you know, using data or AI or might be new science, new biology. So all kinds of innovation All right, lovely. That is a very interesting focus and we'll definitely talk a little bit more about that. But, let's start with a standard question, for all our feces. Can you just tell us quickly about what you investing from with pillar? We see what stage ever check size? And what industry the investing? Yeah. So pillar is a seed stage focused fund based in Boston. We are focused on writing, you know, all kinds of Industries, but as I said, mostly Innovation, we do.
2:29 Right now, about 1/3 software, 1/3 biology, and 1/3 crypto. And our typical check size is 2 million, but it might be 50k up to 6 million, sort of fits the situation. We have, we're on our third fund and our third one is 170 million and so we have a total of 350 million under management about 50 or 60 deal so far. Nice. Congratulations on. Getting to that level and looking forward to seeing that number grow. I'm hopeful that's in five years. I'm going to interview you with your Force funds and we're going to talk about some more fun stuff.
3:10 But now let's talk about your previous company. Let's talk about those three companies that you have lounged. Let's just briefly touch on to each one and then focus on eating because it appears to be the most interesting one that you have run so far. So, first question is, how many of those three have actually Seeded, AKA exits. IP Odes were acquired or anything that can be remotely close to a successful actress. Okay. So Inc was the one that had three down rounds and but then ultimately sold for half a billion dollars. So ice I'm gonna count that as a success you had you know, over 100 million devices, sold with E, Ink electronic paper screens and including all the On Kindle Paperwhite, seu Z ink and a bunch of other devices. A bunch of electronic shelf, price labels. I think total consumer purchases of that either category enabled by that technology is over 10 billion dollars. So that's a success, definitely success. Yeah.
4:14 And then after that, you know, I sold that company. It took a year off, I travel around the world with my family and came back. I think like a lot of Founders Who Sold her first company sort of consumed with the idea that I should Should try to do something very risky and very positive for Humanity. And so my next to Ventures were sort of science moonshots. One was a new kind of alternative nuclear energy, that was safer cleaner and cheaper that raise capital from Peter teal. And another was a cure for cancer that would polarize macrophages, so that the macrophages would fight solid tumors and, you know, neither of those succeeded.
4:54 The Nuclear One ran into A new political Administration that was kind of, didn't believe in the value of clean energy. Let's just say that. Yeah, and became very hard. And what we did with that is we we open sourced all of our science. So everything we found out we put out in the public domain, so others could stand on our shoulders. So, is that a success or not? I mean, in a way we're moving the ball forward on this better form of nuclear energy and then the cancer cure. We were able to A show with less than a million dollars of spending that it was not going to be, you know, not going to be a good enough, cancer cure. There's a lot of things that are like mildly helpful, but in order to get through, and make a drug, which takes a billion dollars of capital, it has to be really excellent. And we were able show very quickly that this was good, but not great.
5:48 And we stopped the project. And so in a way I view that, as success in the sense that, you know, my goal is a As a business person is too is you can't change the laws of physics. So what you want to do with a deep Tech is find out very quickly whether it's going to work or not the kind of disprove your own thesis and we were able to find out quickly and efficiently that this didn't replicate robustly enough to justify company and okay, we shut it down and then it was time for the fourth thing and that's when I switched over to venture capital. So I could try to do many of these projects in parallel. Perfect, love that story of the The journey towards VC and hopefully you'll keep doing some good stuff for the humanity here.
6:33 And yeah, I mean that was definitely a success. If your first you have proved that one of the options is just not working so other people will not spend their time doing it so that is definitely a success but let's talk about the success that was successful in the financial way as well. So let's talk about eating. First of all, you have raised Ten rounds out of those Ten rounds. Three rounds were down Route. So let's start by In our listeners, what a Down Round is and was the problem with the Jammer out. So, Russ game just briefly, explain that. And why do VCS don't like down rounds? Okay. Okay. Well, of course, the when you raising Capital you'll pick a share price you might raise your seed round at a dollar, a share and that might represent say 10 million valuation and the next round 50, in the next round 200.
7:22 In the case of you think we got up to our series, D was a 300 million dollar valuation and wood. Raised about 100 million and so a Down Round is you go to raise your next round and the company's not doing that well, and it's not on the trajectory that would justify a continued increase in share price. And you can't even do a flat round, which would be the same share price, really? There's no takers and you're going to have to decrease the valuation. And this is really bad for VC's, in a couple of respects. Number one, they have to recognize losses and it makes them embarrassed. They're LPS, number two, there's a for you as a Founder.
8:03 The way that most VC comes in is as preferred stock. So most VCS are going to get all their money back before you make anything, right? So, if the price goes down, basically, they need to own a substantial portion of what's left. So, if I raised a hundred million on 300 and the price went down to 50, then then I get nothing and they all have to take a future. Percent right off and I and now the manager team owns nothing. And so there's a big fight. It's almost like going through a bankruptcy and every party it's a very complicated negotiation because each party might or might not put in a few more dollars to keep it going and everybody has to approve the final deal. And there's a question of due to management team get some more stock in the new entity going forward. And if so, which managers were to blame and should be fired in? Which stay so it's a mess.
8:54 It's like going through a bankruptcy, right? And sound like that. So let's talk how you survived three of those and second question right away. Were those consecutive was it just like an unfortunate couple of years or was it a different times? Just because of XYZ reasons, but those were different reasons. Yes, there are consecutive. Let's see. Where's I said? We'd raised a lot of capital to get up to a three million valuation it during the frothy years in the early 2000s. So the internet era was pumping all the prices and so we found it easy to raise capital and then one tactic we used for something industrial, like, you know, display, some VCS won't touch that.
9:40 So you need to get other sources of capital. We did a lot of deals with big companies. Motorola Intel Phillips have 12 different like Fortune, 500 size companies took a lot of work. Well, a big company it's generally not price sensitive so you can jack the valuation up and we did. And so we had a very high valuation, but as the product, you know, we ran into product problems, we were able to finish the product. We spread our, we had so much cash. We thought we'd just try lots of different things. We spread ourselves too thin. You know, hindsight is We should have just focused on one thing so but when it's easy to raise Capital you start to spend it without really thinking that through. And then when we had our first down round I think we made a classic mistake which is that the investors were found it so painful that we did a partial down round which is a big mistake.
10:36 So instead of going from 300 down to 3 and restarting, you know really early and wiping out all the old people all the old investors and just having the new investors In we went from 300 down to 40. So the old investors still had a steak and they were still at the table. They were still you know, really complaining about the the Down Round And so basically the next year we still hadn't reached the market. Probably the market price would have been 5 million but we still kept a partially artificially inflated valuation. And so with deep Tech, you know, at the beginning if you say you've got some great breakthrough in our case, All the ability to have paper that could rewrite itself you know, a complete Library of Congress in the palm of your hand. Very exciting stuff and so you get this great buzz but then you get this trough of disillusionment and at that moment you have to raise capital. I mean, the actual value is very low. It was shown that the tech was very hard to commercialize. So anyway, my point is, if you have to do a Down Round, you should bring it all the way.
11:40 This is my advice to that. I give now to CEOs. If you're in this situation, you want to Get it down as low as you can and I thought Constantine that as a CEO you know my job was to try to preserve my shareholders and so that's why I thought 40 was better than five. Yeah, but really it's very damaging for you not to sort of admit reality and go all the way down and one reason is every time there's a Down Round remember all that all the Common Stocks getting wiped out. So you have to restart your vest in clock. So who you fooling? So what happens is you like, okay I've been in this deal for. I've been working on this for seven years. Now I have four more years to go and then you few delay, the full day of reckoning for an extra year to buy, sort of trying to re hype the the down around. You just restart your black again. Two years later when I had three in a row. Yeah.
12:32 And you know what you want to do? If that happens is you'll have a choice. Do you take options or do you try to buy back into the new at the new cheaper? Doc and for tax reasons. It's much better to buy back in because you get capital gains. And so the first time I bought back in for like a few tens of thousands, by the time, the second time I had to buy back in for about, you know, equal to the mortgage on my house. Oh, goodbye. Back in the third time, I had to pledge in. Am I to take an amount of debt on my personal balance sheet, which was equal, to Triple the mortgage on my house? Yikes. And I get home. I never really discussed that with anybody in my family, but I figured if I went back into like management consulting and I work for 20 years, I'd be able to repay that debt. So it wasn't really irresponsible. But, you know, it's a, it's a really risky situation. And again, if you go all the way down, then you'd only have to do that once and it still managing.
13:32 So basically, you're going to take a haircut, get the buzz cut, right? Heck at the bus cut for sure, don't try to go. Estelle at this point, but let's talk about how the common stock is being wiped out. Can you briefly explain how the system works? So investors definitely keep their preferred shares what happens to the common stock. So let's just described a scenario. Let's say you have five investors. All of them. Holds, let's say 50% of your company in preferred stocks you as a Founder. Hold the rest 50 in Common Stocks. What happens when you down round and let's say you are going from 100 million valuation to 50 million valuation, what's going to happen to your sock?
14:13 So before on paper you guys have evaluation of 100 million and you the founder own 50 million worth but it's common the five investors each own 10 million words so they have 50 million but is preferred. So right now looks like the company split evenly. However, let's say there's some adverse event and now your company drops, it's no longer worth 100. So the way preferred stock works, is its first in line. When you sell the company, And it generally gets all its money back before Common gets anything. So, let's say it goes. Your valuation goes from 100 to 90. It's no longer a 50-50 split now, they get 50 and you only get 40 Value goes down to 80. They get 50.
14:57 You only get 30 value goes down the 70. They give you 20, you all the way down to 50. Now, at that point they own all of the company and you get none and the common stock is worthless and if you want to raise Cash at that point. What they'll do they usually don't erase your shares. They just like introduce an extra zero sort of like you know the currency and Argentina and Zimbabwe or something. Just add more zeros and you just get washed out and so that and then they might give you new options in the sort of with the extra zeros on them at the end. Hmm. Right. That is a very unfortunate event to run into but congrats on Surviving 30. Those that is some high-level maneuvering right there and you did have a successful exit at the end. So it was not for nothing, just one more question and we'll move on to talk more about prvc.
15:54 Specifically ends your current Journey, but how did you manage to survive three, how do you manage, was it just your negotiation skills? Was it just you know investors who believed in you so much that they were like you know when we're going to stick to it, we're going to throw in some more money. We're going to make sure that this company survive sore You know, x amount of years. Well, I think this is the general topic. I see this is how do you as a CEO report? Bad news to your investors? And there's really, you know, one approach is I'm going to hide it, I'm going to downplay it. I'm just gonna try to emphasize accentuate the positive, but I think one thing in hindsight, we made a lot of mistakes. But one thing we did well is that we just gave the even-handed unvarnished reality.
16:41 And so I think even though the results were Results that were not good people. Trusted at least that they're being told the truth and as long as you then yeah you do need to find at least one anchor investor who is willing to make a bet on you and who will lead the recap. But as long as that's happening and people leave, you have your integrity and you can articulate a good plan and explain why why it's a better plan then? At least some investors will want to come along and they want to have seat at the table and they were there for good reasons. And so I think being clear with people and and giving the them the story they can trust, don't wait to share, bad.
17:26 News is a big element, the other element. I'll just throw in is that, you know, your job as a CEO keeps changing the company's growing event removing really. It's like you have a new job description every six months and if you don't prepare yourself to keep learning, you won't survive. So, One thing that we did during that time, which try very hard to keep listening to feedback, keep improving keep reading books, keep taking classes, keep listening to podcast and just improve yourself everyday. And you know, if people can see that you've got an upward trajectory they may be frustrated is not all the way up yet, but they will. They'll be your fans and they'll wait patiently more patiently for you as long as they can see, you're doing your best to improve.
18:11 Right. Yeah, honesty is the key. Is in the relationship with investors one. You feel their trust. You're done. You are done. And the word will spread. For sure that part definitely does not stay hidden for long. So on this note, let's move on and talk about jewelry. See at last. So, one of the unique traits of the fun is actually that most of the managers managers and partners in the fund have Have experience building their own companies, right? Mmm. Yeah, that's right. And how transferrable do you think the experience is? So from what I've seen personally by interviewing hundreds of investors? Is that a lot of them have experience building the companies but is just not relevant?
18:56 Or they think that some investors, especially those who are younger and those who have opened, just their first fund think that, you know, the business that have built is the Silver Bullet for startups. I'm just going to try to replicate that. That success for every company I invested in, they try to go into the subjects that they don't quite understand. So from your perspective, how transferable is that knowledge that you have acquired by building your own companies for example, That's a great question and I'm in year 5 and I'm still trying to decide that for myself but you know, I think the the material changes with each company. The industry is different, the specifics are different and I also think that it's a great mistake for the VC to think that he or she knows the answer and that it's about transfer of knowledge like you're working together to figure out a puzzle. And so you know the clues are there. R in your.
19:53 You may not know the right answer, but you're on the same side is the founder and trying to figure it out. And what does help a lot is kind of a sense of rhythm of, of process of con of the spirit of just being on an adventure and trying to face Mysteries and not being rattled. When there's setbacks so many or you know, generalize things like how would Do you hire someone or how do you do a good job interview? Or you know, how to explain stock options to someone? How should you write a good pitch deck? So there are certain Universal things that are absolutely transferable.
20:33 And there are other things that I think are about attitude, which I believe, resonate pretty. Well, the founder and certainly, when I was a Founder, I really preferred investors who had been there and done that before. And who also were humble enough. Not to say they had the answer but at least they were with me, totally in spirit. 100% having humble investors who are also knowledgeable. That is a rare combination right there, very hard to find. So if you do run into those definitely crab them and try to get them on your cap table. So on this note, let's move on and talk a little bit more about technicalities and that is the fact that you mentioned that you actually like patents on our pre-interview call. So question is when do the patents make sense? And in which Industries, do they make sense? Yeah, I'm often asked should I file patents? And it can be pretty expensive and I can think of three situations.
21:30 First of all, obviously, if you're deep tech company, and you're truly innovating and you're inventing things that never existed before, you're going to spend a lot of time and money on patents. And actually, I wrote this whole guide called how to build a patent Fortress such as on our website. And that's a good thing to read. If you're, if you're doing that and then the alternative, the other end of the spectrum is somebody who Really inventing a new business model but there is no technical Innovation. So, like we have an investment in conjure, they will bring you furniture for your rental apartment. So you show up, it's already furnished. You leave, they take it away. It's all white glove service and its really nice stuff that's about, you know, a providing a service that meets the needs of Millennials and gen Z, and it's not really a technical question, so there's clearly not going to be a patent there and then in the middle is, let's say that you have an innovation. And it's just a small differentiation, you know, like we use a, you know, something that makes our air conditioner five percent more energy efficient. It's not really going to be blocking the competition, it's just nice.
22:34 And then you would file like one patent just to be able to say your patent pending. So it really looking at the amount of invention and for most people it's either none or one to be able to say you have one and then in but in certain circumstances are going to be spending perhaps And of dollars and you probably know if that's your case. Hmm, right, right. Personally, not a huge fan of fans. But yet deep Tech, that's a different subject. So in that case, he might be excused and just might as well file for that patent. If it does make sense, I see the one thing I'll point out there is true, you're never going to get value from the patent while your startup because you don't have the balance sheet to be able to sue, anybody. Yeah, hatton's are really like in chest. There's the end game.
23:22 The patents are in endgame asset, your acquirer will be able to get value from them. Like, if IBM buys you, they're going to be able to sue someone with them. So you you want to build them up. There are important asset but you're never going to use them which it's a sort of funny irony. But I do think that can be valuable for detox. Hmm, right. And by the way, there is a great movie about specifically that subject about small companies making patents and then be companies just using those patents because they were Realize that they don't have the money to sue them. Cole's the billion-dollar codes recommend to everyone who is interested in looking how cheesy Google is. All right, so on this note, let's move on and talk about the investments in deep debt that you've made. So, is there anything particularly interesting that you would like to share before we wrap up the episode? Well, we have a range of deep Tech Investments and as I said, we're right now doing one third of our investing in biology and bio Tech.
24:26 And all of that is, is in a way. It's a deep Tech. So it's so exciting. And at struggle to pick out one, you know, one we just had now it's a 50 million dollar series, a is cool. A bio Kula is using microbes to manufacture nitrogen. Fertilizer, and so You get fertilizer in a fully sustainable package so you just spray the stuff on your field and then you don't need to put chemicals on your on your soil. And so, it's organic. You can be made in sustainable way. It's not requiring. Any fossil fuels, it doesn't have any nitrogen runoff, so it keeps the nitrogen out of the water and it could be if the yields get to where we want.
25:10 It could be cheaper than haber-bosch and so it could revolutionize the fertilizer industry, which is 100. Our industry. So that's an example of how biology is changing everything that they're in the middle of a great revolution in biology. And so it's new kinds of fertilizer. We also have Investments new kind of synthetic cotton synthetic leather, you know, sustainable coffee, all sorts of products in addition to medicines and cell and tissue therapies being invented. It's a really fertile moment for biology. It sure is. I've definitely heard a ton of invasions in that space and seems like they're being off. Maybe one day, you won't be hungry at last on this notes.
25:54 That whole, let's go to the call to action and Which is, which is the last question of today's episode and it's very simple. Would do you want the listener to do right after this episode is over rust? Okay, go to pillar dot VC and check out something. We have called the founders playlist and this is like a multimedia playground with all sorts of entrepreneurs and investors giving advice on hundreds of different topics and so you can pick out whatever. The problem of the day is that you're facing and check it out and in particular I'll just draw attention to his cool tool. We have, they're called the term sheet greater. So we go out and you raise Capital, you get a term sheet.
26:35 You're like, is this good? These people trying advantage of me. You can just go to our term sheet greater and plug in your term sheet and find out if it's fair or not. Oh, is that technology automate or is it? Someone on the back end, just actually checking it out. We know it's automated. You have sort of Sliders, mmm, really it all term. She's like, there's five or six shots. Yeah, it's really simple. For the VC is pretty. Much multiple choice on each question. Yeah, it's no. We just asked you like, which did they pick? And then you can computer score. Alright, that is very interesting. I'll be sure to leave the link in the description to this episode. As usual, of course, there's gonna be linked to Russ's LinkedIn. And, of course, there's gonna be my Shameless plug in mentioning the course that our team has developed specifically, for Founder's trying to figure out how to reach out to the right investors. If you want to try to figure out how to do that in a right way. Definitely check out the description of this episode because the links are going to be there. And as usually have a good day,